Loading
Tiffany & Co.
Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle
Median resale value
$950
Based on 6 listings — treat as indicative
$550middle 50% of listings$1,142+
Based on 6 listings — treat as indicative
Every active listing we track, bucketed by asking price. The band you buy in tells you more than the average does.
6 active listings. Median asking price $950. The middle 50% ask between $673 and $995.
Counts here cover listings with a known price, so they can be lower than the active total above.
| Listing | Posted | Condition | Authenticity | Price ↑ | vs median | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Fashionphile | 4/23/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $550 | 42% below the median price | View on Fashionphile |
 | Fashionphile | 10/10/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $595 | 37% below the median price | View on Fashionphile |
 | Fashionphile | 10/20/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $905 | 5% below the median price | View on Fashionphile |
 | Fashionphile | 10/8/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $995 | 5% above the median price | View on Fashionphile |
 | Fashionphile | 10/10/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $995 | 5% above the median price | View on Fashionphile |
 | Fashionphile | 10/17/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $1,150 | 21% above the median price | View on Fashionphile |
 | FashionphileSold | 8/26/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $475 | 50% below the median price | Sold10/8/2026 |
 | FashionphileSold | 8/13/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $595 | 37% below the median price | Sold9/13/2026 |
 | FashionphileSold | 7/12/2026 | — | AuthenticatedFashionphile in-house authentication | $765 | 19% below the median price | Sold10/17/2026 |
We currently track 9 listings for the Tiffany & Co. Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle, with prices ranging from $550 – $1,150, from Fashionphile.
The Tiffany & Co. Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle is a pre-owned Tiffany & Co. jewelry piece available for purchase across multiple resale platforms. Shop 9 active listings with prices ranging from $550 – $1,150. Find this item on Fashionphile. 7 listings are professionally authenticated, giving you added peace of mind when buying pre-owned.
Current market prices by condition and authenticity, based on active listings.
| Status | Listings | Price range |
|---|---|---|
| Authenticated / VerifiedListings with third-party authentication or platform verification | 7 | $550 – $1,150avg $884 |
| Marketplace | Listings | Total value |
|---|---|---|
| Fashionphile | 6 | $5.2K |
| Total | 6 | $5.2K |
Listing counts in the condition and platform tables are filtered subsets (listings with a known condition or price). The “active listings” figure at the top of the page reflects all tracked active listings and may be higher.
