Loading
Tudor
Black Bay Fifty-Eight
Median resale value
$5,350Unchanged over 90 days
Based on 11 listings — treat as indicative
$4,975middle 50% of listings$5,645+
Based on 11 listings — treat as indicative
Every active listing we track, bucketed by asking price. The band you buy in tells you more than the average does.
11 active listings. Median asking price $5,350. The middle 50% ask between $5,225 and $5,500.
Counts here cover listings with a known price, so they can be lower than the active total above.
| Listing | Posted | Condition | Authenticity | Price ↑ | vs median | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $4,975 | 7% below the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 5/3/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $4,975 | 7% below the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,225 | 2% below the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 5/3/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,225 | 2% below the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,275 | 1% below the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,350 | At the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 5/3/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,350 | At the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,475 | 2% above the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,525 | 3% above the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,600 | 5% above the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 5/2/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $5,650 | 6% above the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $22,550 | 321% above the median price | View on WatchBox |
 | WatchBox | 4/28/2026 | Good | AuthenticatedWatchBox Certified Pre-Owned | $40,500 | 657% above the median price | View on WatchBox |
We currently track 13 listings for the Tudor Black Bay Fifty-Eight, with prices ranging from $4,975 – $5,650, from WatchBox.
The TUDOR Black Bay Fifty-Eight exemplifies the brand's dedication to precision and craftsmanship, embodying a modern interpretation of the classic dive watch. Inspired by TUDOR's rich maritime heritage, this model features a 39mm stainless steel case that strikes the perfect balance between robustness and elegance. The matte black dial is adorned with luminous hour markers and hands, ensuring optimal legibility in low-light conditions, a hallmark of TUDOR's design ethos. This timepiece is equipped with a unidirectional rotating bezel, which is crafted from anodized aluminum, offering both style and functionality for underwater exploration. The Black Bay Fifty-Eight is powered by TUDOR's in-house caliber MT5402, a COSC-certified chronometer that guarantees accuracy and reliability. With its vintage-inspired aesthetics and contemporary performance, this watch is a versatile addition to any collection, suitable for both casual and formal occasions. The model runs true to size and features a comfortable fit, making it a favorite among enthusiasts who appreciate durability without sacrificing style.
The Tudor Black Bay Fifty-Eight is a pre-owned Tudor watch available for purchase across multiple resale platforms. Shop 13 active listings with prices ranging from $4,975 – $5,650. Find this item on WatchBox. Listings are available in Good condition, so you can choose the quality and price point that suits you. 11 listings are professionally authenticated, giving you added peace of mind when buying pre-owned.
Current market prices by condition and authenticity, based on active listings.
| Condition | Listings | Price range |
|---|---|---|
| Good | 11 | $4,975 – $5,650avg $5,330 |
| Status | Listings | Price range |
|---|---|---|
| Authenticated / VerifiedListings with third-party authentication or platform verification | 11 | $4,975 – $5,650avg $5,330 |
| Marketplace | Listings | Total value |
|---|---|---|
| WatchBox | 13 | $121.7K |
| Total | 13 | $121.7K |
Listing counts in the condition and platform tables are filtered subsets (listings with a known condition or price). The “active listings” figure at the top of the page reflects all tracked active listings and may be higher.
